ISO 17025 or ISO 9001: Which one is better?
As a calibration company we are sometimes asked which is better ISO 9001 or ISO 17025 certification. That really is the wrong question. Both of these International standards are excellent. The reason we said it is the wrong question is because they each have a particular focus. What is the difference between ISO 9001 and ISO 17025?
ISO 9001 is a standard designed for the manufacturing and service sector and focuses the Quality
Management System towards those major groupings.
ISO 17025 is focused on calibration and testing. You will see many similarities in the Quality Management System of both standards.
All the technical journals are writing about the changes in ISO 9001 that are scheduled to roll out this year. One key aspect being discussed is Risk Management. The paradigm changes in ISO 9001 are already being discussed in regards to ISO 17025.
Let's take a side by side look.
|ISO 9001||ISO 17025|
|Section 2||Normative References||Normative References|
|Section 3||Terms and Definitions||Terms and Definitions|
|Section 4||Quality Management System||Management Requirements|
|Section 5||Management Responsibility||Technical requirements|
|Section 6||Resource Management||NA|
|Section 7||Product Realization||NA|
|Section 8||Measurement, Analysis and Improvement||NA|
Both standards address:
- Document Control
- Service to the Customer
- Corrective Action
- Management Reviews
- Control of Non-conforming Product
- Control of Data
A few key differences between ISO 17025 and ISO 9001.
1. ISO 17025 requires a demonstration of technical competence.
2. ISO 17025 requires traceability of measurements to standards.
3. ISO 17025 requires the application of measurement uncertainty.
Which one is better? Still not the right question. They are different.
Want to learn more?:
ILAC (International Laboratory Accreditation Cooperation) and NCSLI (National Conference of Standards Laboratories) have written an excellent white paper on this topic.
Visit our International Standards used in Calibration page for more on standards used in calibration.
You may also want to read this article from our friends at 3D Engineering Solutions: ISO9001 vs ISO17025 vs AS9100 – Why It Matters When It Comes To Your Metrology Needs